★★★★☆
There is a lot going on in Off-Key. Classism, racism, feminism, academic pressure, friendship, ambition, mental health and the pursuit of a dream all find their way into this coming-of-age drama. Yet its two performers keep the chaos grounded in something much more personal: two best friends slowly realising they may no longer want the same future.
The biggest asset of Off-Key is undoubtedly its actors. Salma Muse as Ruqqiyah and Mannan Guled as Sabrin bring an energy that makes their friendship believable from the outset. There is a natural rhythm between them, which becomes increasingly interesting as their ambitions pull them in opposite directions. Sabrin is quietly chasing a future in music, while Ruqqiyah’s frustrations with school push her towards a very different kind of rebellion.
Fatima Ali Omar’s script gives the production plenty to work with. Despite the number of themes competing for attention, the story moves naturally and the characters remain at its centre. The work of director Neetu Singh and the wider creative team also deserves credit for bringing a story with so many moving parts together without allowing it to become completely overwhelming.
The production’s sound and lighting are particularly effective. A recurring flickering of the lights, accompanied by sound effects, becomes almost a language of its own. During the panic attacks, the noise represents something overwhelming to the person experiencing it, while everyone else continues around them as though nothing has changed. The world does not stop because you are struggling.
Sabrin’s identity as a musician, however, feels like a small missed opportunity. With music being such an important part of her aspirations, there is surprisingly little musicality within the production itself. A sneak peek performance into Sabrin talent could have given her dream an even stronger presence. Of course, a musical element brings its own practical and production challenges, and the absence does not detract from the story’s flow, but it would have been a beautiful addition.
The decision to keep Off-Key on a single set works well for most of the production, keeping the focus on the characters. During the concert sequence, however, the limitations briefly become noticeable, taking me out of the illusion. Fortunately, the actors quickly pull the audience back in, creating an “invisible venue” through their commitment to the scene.
The ending is perhaps the production’s biggest question mark. With so many ideas introduced, there is a lingering feeling that we do not quite get to see where all of them lead. The abrupt ending does leave space for the audience to think, but I found myself wanting to see what came next.
Still, Off-Key finds its strongest moments in its people: the friendship at its centre, the performers carrying it, and the creative team giving the story room to breathe. I would love to see what these two actors do next. If Off-Key is any indication, they have plenty more to say.
Image Credits: Sheffield Theatres
